Page 10, 10th March 1989

10th March 1989
Page 10
Page 10, 10th March 1989 — Never intended to be angels

Report an error

Noticed an error on this page?
If you've noticed an error in this article please click here to report it.



Related articles

Life Can Be A Messy Business

Page 10 from 2nd September 1988

Ronald Rolheiser

Page 10 from 28th July 1995

Darwinism And The Faith

Page 8 from 20th August 2010

Saints For Complex People

Page 10 from 22nd February 1991

Ronald Rolheiser

Page 10 from 4th November 1994

Never intended to be angels

A THEIST IC philosopher, Maurice Merleau-Ponty, once commented on why he did not believe in God. The reason, he stated, is because ambiguity is the fundamental phenomenological fact within our existence and a belief in God is not consistent with that experience.

That phrase, in an abstract way, expresses something we all experience, namely, life is utterly messy; so messy in fact that it can leave one wondering whether indeed there exists an all-powerful and caring God. Nobody goes through life antiseptically, without dirt, pain, mess and death.

But, unlike Merleau-Ponty, I believe in God precisely for that reason. Life may be messy, but it is real, not plastic. We aren't Swiss clocks, infallibly ordered, made to tick meticulously, precise and antiseptic.

Rather our lives are anything but ordered and clocklike. We cannot live without messiness, complications, and much emotional and physical pain.

It begins when we are horn. Birth is a messy process which causes pain, dictates involvement, and complicates peoples' lives irrevocably. Living does too! Work, interrelations, love, sex, friendship, ageing, all of these are complex, earthy, messy businesses which are always at least partially full of pain, pettiness, limit, compromise, and death. They are full of joy and meaning too, but these are seldom given purely.

Moreover, no-one goes through life without having his or her dignity, freedom, and dreams frustrated and stepped on. There is no antiseptic route through life. The whiteness of our baptismal robes, the purity of our hearts, minds, and bodies, and the freshness of our youth, sully and dirty and bear the stain of living.

As we grow older, Gerard Manley Hopkins' words ring ever more true: "And all is smeared with trade, bleared, smeared with toil, And wears man's smudge and shares man's smell, the soil."

Often this leaves us discouraged and questioning. More seriously, this often leads to a subtle despair. Stated simply, the algebra of this despair, and ultimately of all despair, reads like this: If all is muddled, then all is permitted.

That attitude is viral and deadly. it is perhaps the worst temptation faced by an adult. Because of it we sell ourselves out, give up, throw dignity and dreams to the wind, and settle for second best. This single factor is perhaps at the root of most of the infidelity, sexual irresponsibility, and unbelief within our culture. When we sell out our dignity and dreams, then, like Mcrleau-Ponty, we will have trouble experiencing God. The Highest is more clearly experienced when we are giving ourselves over to what is highest. The messiness of life also leaves us tempted in another way, namely, we are tempted to try to live antiseptically.

Since we cannot live and love deeply without hurting, without pettiness, without enslaving and humiliating entanglements, without smear, we opt not to live and love deeply al all. So we hang loose, refusing depth. We stay away from all that might hurt — or heal — us deeply. In doing this we make life plastic antiseptic, clean, without dirt and smell, but totally lifeless and without meaning, like a plastic rose. We need to accept the contours of our existence.

We are not angels, free, soaring spirits, unencumbered by the limits of time and flesh.

Our souls are born enfleshed in soil, pain, blood and smell. We were never intended to be angels. But with that comes a special dignity, the dignity that a real rose possesses over a plastic One.

Peter Meinke once wrote a sonnet honouring the death of the man who invented the plastic rose:

"The Man who invented the plastic rose is dead, behold his mask

his undying flawless blossoms never close.

But guard his grave unbending through the dark.

lie understood neither heauty nor flowers, Which catch our hearts in nets as soft as sky And binds us with a thread of fragile hours; Flowers are beautiful becaus: they die.

Beauty without the perishable pulse is dry and sterile, an abandoned stage With false forests. But the results

Support this man's invention: He knew his age;

A vision of our tearless time discloses Artilicial men sniffing plastic roses."

blog comments powered by Disqus