Page 12, 15th January 2010

15th January 2010
Page 12
Page 12, 15th January 2010 — Scrooge: from lonely capitalist to true Christian

Report an error

Noticed an error on this page?
If you've noticed an error in this article please click here to report it.



Related articles

On The Screens By Freda Bruce Lockhart

Page 6 from 17th December 1971

Daring To Disbelieve The Global Warming 'gospel'

Page 18 from 6th April 2007

I Survived My

Page 10 from 2nd May 2008

Public Cinema

Page 16 from 6th December 1935

Catholic Jewels Discovered In A Car Boot Sale

Page 10 from 19th September 2008

Scrooge: from lonely capitalist to true Christian

Charlie Hegarty Notebook

he one advantage of living in a consumerist, throwaway society is the amount of rich and strange pickings you can acquire from what has been discarded. Only last week I was skulking in our local public library among the other tramps and scoundrels when I discovered a “for sale” shelf of DVDs at £1 each. Having exactly £2 in my pocket I came home with The Passion of Ayn and and Scrooge. I consumed both of them by eye in quick succession and, as with the way of certain potent images, they have been re-playing in my mind ever since.

I knew almost nothing of Ayn Rand and had bought the DVD because the estimable Helen Mirren was playing the title role. Now, of course, I know more than enough and have relegated her to my mental Bluebeard’s closet of ne’er-dowells and weirdos, along with Aleister Crowley, Baron Corvo and others. If Joan Bakewell was once described as “the thinking man’s crumpet” I would describe Ms Rand (she couldn’t be anything but “Ms”) as the thinking man’s dominatrix. Russian-born, influenced – naturally – by Nietzsche and living in the States, she once dominated certain sections of that rampantly individualist, capitalist world with her black leather-booted ideas about society and the whiplash of her contempt for the poor and weak.

Apparently she invented a philosophical system called Objectivism. I won’t try to explain this, even if I could understand it, so will leave readers to make what they will of her most famous sayings, such as “money is the barometer of a society’s virtue” and “Civilisation is the process of setting man free from men”. Helen Mirren, of course, played all this up to the hilt. It made Margaret Thatcher look positively cuddly.

What has Ayn Rand to do with Scrooge, apart from being placed beside him on the bargain shelf at my local library? Well, Scrooge started out as a selfish capitalist, whose heart was hardened against the poor and the weak. “Are there no prisons? Are there no workhouses?” he would expostulate as he made his daily way to and from his counting-house to his home. Any plea for help or mercy was met with “Bah! Humbug!” which is undoubtedly what Ms Rand would have said if she hadn’t invented her own more pompous idiom.

But Scrooge changed, which is why the film – with the incomparable Alastair Sim in the title role – is rolled out every Christmas, to delight and warm the hearts of all who watch it. Dickens’s genius, a mixture of high drama, vivid characterisation, linguistic magic and whatever else he could throw into this sublime story for comical and sentimental effect, sees to that. Scrooge changed; from a shrivelledup skinflint of a lonely Rand-capitalist to a human being capable of loving others and not just himself. Scrooge changed – and thus was capable of receiving the warmth and kindness that lay all around him, notably from his nephew and the Cratchit family.

Ms Rand’s thoughts on the hereafter are tossed off with acid terseness: “When I die, I hope to go to heaven, wherever the hell that is.” That hell lay within, as it had with Scrooge, building himself a gold coffin with his bare hands. But Scrooge changed.

And I am left wondering on the random purchase of two discarded films from the throw-away society and the thoughts they have engendered. We are still within the portals of the New Year. Timid resolutions are not enough; it is time to change. As Tiny Tim would say: “God bless us, every one!”

blog comments powered by Disqus