Page 6, 19th May 1967

19th May 1967
Page 6
Page 6, 19th May 1967 — And now the mini-critic
Close

Report an error

Noticed an error on this page?
If you've noticed an error in this article please click here to report it.

Tags

Organisations: University of Manchester

Share


Related articles

Foes To Aid Of Longford

Page 5 from 8th December 1972

The Phoenix Is Alive And Well Ds. Charterhouse Die Chronicle

Page 10 from 25th May 1984

Attack On The Catholic Case

Page 3 from 15th July 1966

Hopkins In Poets' Corner

Page 4 from 12th December 1975

Fire Destroys Au Pair Club

Page 11 from 17th January 1975

And now the mini-critic

By Fr. PETER LEVI, S.J.

Fifty Worts of English Literature We Could Do Without, by Brigid Brophy, Michael Levy and Charles Osborne (Rapp and Carroll, 25s).

THIS is a series of fifty small

scale attacks, each of two or three pages, on great or popular books and poems. The attacks are always flippantly written and sometimes bumptiously conceived.

The works attacked are of uneven merit, but the attacks are of an even and always more astonishing stupidity. It is amazing that so insubstantial a collection of mini-essays should have reached print. The experience of reading it is without any pleasures; one suffers all the pains of extreme boredom without the relief of a very profound indignation.

There is even a dimension of nightmare about the degree to which these authors evidently admire their own witty powers. It is a fundamental of criticism that one ought not to make jokes without making a ca-se. Perhaps I shall be accused of the same self-admiring folly, but I protest that this review is not a joke.

Nor is it a matter of loyalty and prejudice, but simply of wanting a decent standard of honesty and sobriety in English prose. The attacks, even when they are in some way just, are exaggerated to a point where they put themselves out of court. How can people permit themselves to write this kind of nonsense?

• A long overdue reprint of James Isodor Mombert's edition of William Tyndale's translation of The Pentateuch (Centaur Press, I26s) is published today. Professor F. F. Bruce, Rylands Professor of Biblical Criticism and Exegesis in the University of Manchester, supplies a new introduction in which he points out that our detachment from the controversies of the sixteenth century now happily allows us to appreciate Tyndale's salty, if anti-Papal. wit.




blog comments powered by Disqus