Page 5, 20th March 1970

20th March 1970
Page 5
Page 5, 20th March 1970 — A closed

Report an error

Noticed an error on this page?
If you've noticed an error in this article please click here to report it.



Related articles

Orthodoxy Of Normative Mass The Modern Mass By Hugh Ross

Page 6 from 6th March 1970

Our Lord's Words Not Changed

Page 5 from 3rd April 1970

Intention Of 'new' Mass

Page 5 from 13th March 1970

The White Heat Of The Liturgical Revolution

Page 6 from 19th June 1970

Clarity Hindered By Emotion

Page 5 from 20th March 1970

A closed

circle of experts'

CANON I. B. O'CONNELL'S review (March 6) of Hugh Ross Williamson's "The Modern Mass" contains several errors of fact.

The new rite of Mass was not "prepared by the most competent body of bishops and liturgists (the Concilium".) It was in fact compiled by a closed circle of "experts" one of whom was reprimanded by Pope John for his unorthodox views.

Far from being accepted joyfully by the bishops of the Roman Rite a version of the Mass substantially the same as the new rite was decisively rejected by the bishops in 1967.

Let there be no doubt about the fact that the new rite has been imposed without any consultation or consideration for those to whom it causes difficulties of conscience, The bishops, to their shame. have accepted this position without question.

During the 400 years of its use no doubt was ever raised as to the orthodoxy of the Tridentine Mass. It is not even questioned today.

On the other hand, no amount of assurances from the Pope or the Congregation for Divine Worship can conceal the underlying unorthodox premises of the new rite.

Canon O'Connell displays both his ignorance and his lack of understanding when he characterises Mr. Ross Williamson's hook as "mischievous". Mr. Ross Williamson's able expression of the genuine doubts felt by many Catholics regarding the new rite commands more respect than the Canon's total unconcern for the spiritual needs of a not inconsiderable number of the faithful.

W. A. Jones Dover.

blog comments powered by Disqus