Page 1, 21st March 1997

21st March 1997
Page 1
Page 1, 21st March 1997 — Minister fails to guarantee bug-free Confessionals

Report an error

Noticed an error on this page?
If you've noticed an error in this article please click here to report it.



Related articles

Catholic Mps Move To Safeguard Confessional

Page 1 from 31st January 1997

Howard U-turn On Bugs

Page 1 from 21st February 1997

Page 3 Opinion: Ban The Confessional Bug

Page 3 from 31st January 1997

Now Austria Faces Bugs In The Confessional

Page 2 from 2nd May 1997

Outrage As Home Office Plans To Bug Confessionals

Page 1 from 24th January 1997

Minister fails to guarantee bug-free Confessionals


HOME OFFICE Minister David Maclean announced last week that the Government will not make explicit in its Police Bill its guarantee to protect the Confessional from bugging by police.

But Mr Maclean sought to reassure the Bill's standing committee that police will respect Home Secretary Michael Howard's pledge to safeguard the Confessional, even though this pledge will not appear in the legislation.

Michael Connarty, Labour MP for Falkirk East, was angered by the revelation. He told the Herald that the Government has a record of "leaving their options open".

Mr Maclean told the committee that the extension of safeguards to other faiths

beyond those made to Catholics and Anglicans would be stretching the remit of the Bill "far too wide".

In reply, Mr Connarty said: "The Government refuse to put into statute that Confessionals will not be bugged by the police. The police have said in their code of practice that they won't, but such exclusions can not be guaranteed if not put into statute."

"If a faith has a Confessional system, it should be respected. The Government should have taken the trouble to think that through. If they don't they will leave a large hole in it and face the accusation that they have not named, defined or excluded the Confessional because they countenanced abusing it.

"Many faiths, not only Christian, have a Confessional. They should all be treated with respect."

He told the Herald that he believed that a later amendment to the Bill could ultimately satisfy concerns of Catholics, with bugging of the Confessional made clearly illegal.

However, Edward Leigh, Conservative MP for Gainsborough & Horncastle and a practising Catholic, was satisfied by Mr Maclean's explanation. "I think we got what we wanted," he told the Herald.

Public awareness of the Confessional loophole in the Police Bill was first raised in January, when commentator William Oddie called for a "Catholic Herald amendment".

blog comments powered by Disqus