Page 7, 22nd February 2002

22nd February 2002
Page 7
Page 7, 22nd February 2002 — Defending Pius XII against 'unjust' critics

Report an error

Noticed an error on this page?
If you've noticed an error in this article please click here to report it.


Organisations: National Socialist Party


Related articles

From Mr Paul Crawley Sir. Gerard Noel Is A Constant And,...

Page 7 from 22nd February 2002

From Dr Michael Straiton

Page 7 from 22nd February 2002

Pius Vii — A Hero Of The Anti-napoleonic Resistance

Page 6 from 1st February 2002

Pius Xii: The Great Pacelli Or Hitler's Pope?

Page 7 from 8th October 1999

The 'silence' Of Pius Xii

Page 7 from 29th March 2002

Defending Pius XII against 'unjust' critics

Franz Mr Vincent Whitehouse

Sir. In his "Faith of our Fathers" article (Feb 1), Gerard Noel compares unfavourably Pius VII's dealing with Napoleon and Pius Xll's with Adolf Hitler. According to his reading of events (backwards, by the way, as he denigrates others doing!) Pius XII persisted in appeasing the Third Reich instead of confronting it head-on, as Pius VII eventually did with Napoleon.

However regrettably, the National Socialist Party was legally elected to government. Vatican diplomatic recognition was therefore unexceptional. All European States acted similarly. Recognition did not equate with appeasement, as Gerard Noel seems confusedly to think.

Efforts to besmirch Eugenio Pacelli (Pius XII) concentrate on his alleged wartime record of insensitivity and inertia apropos the persecution of the Jewish People and other ethnic groups, political and social opponents. Well-documented but frequently ignored or downplayed evidence shows the assiduousness with which Pius XII did all he morally and physically could, by diplomatic and clandestine means, to aid and rescue victims of Nazi' policies. Dutch bishops attempting a more radical and confrontational approach, provoked even more deportations.

An "appeaser" Eugenio Pacelli most definitely was not, as Jewish tributes to him, during and after the Second World War. amply testify. It seems left to a Catholic commentator to suggest otherwise.

Yours faithfully, VINCENT WHITEHOUSE London SW 20

blog comments powered by Disqus