Page 4, 25th October 1985

25th October 1985
Page 4
Page 4, 25th October 1985 — Just plain Jesus will do, thank you

Report an error

Noticed an error on this page?
If you've noticed an error in this article please click here to report it.


Organisations: Catholic Church
People: Simon Peter, Pilate
Locations: Chavakcheri


Related articles

Third World Theologians: Part I

Page 5 from 7th June 1985

Who Judas Really Was

Page 4 from 26th May 1978

The Theologian Who Cocked A Snook At Objective Truth

Page 5 from 30th October 1998

Doubts Queries

Page 10 from 21st July 2000

Why The Vatican Took Fright

Page 5 from 30th October 1998

Just plain Jesus will do, thank you

"CHRIST IN context" by Fr Tissa Balasuriya (June 7), is not true to its title. "Jesus in context" would be more faithful to the text.

We are told, that even Jesus asked his disciples, "Who do men say I am?" But then like Bacon's Pilate in his essay on 'Truth' Fr Tissa's Jesus does not wait for an answer.

Matthew on the contrary portrays Jesus not only as waiting for and listening to all the answers but also as asking a further question to which Peter gives the answer and gets the imprimatur. If the words 'Christ' and `Christology' as used in the article conform to Peter's confession, why cut the story short even at the risk of making Jesus appear a cynic like Pilate, I wonder. A subtle but clear intent to leave out the kernel of the story in order to let us feed on the husk and swallow his indoctrination is the charge against the author, as he could not recount the whole incident without discrediting his

discovery that the Latin American answer is as good as any.

As Jesus was not prepared to accept any and every answer, this new one stands rejected like all the others reported by Matthew save Peter's, because for these rediscoverers of (Latin) America Jesus is not what Simon Peter and good old Christopher Columbus confessed, "the Christ, the Son of the living God".

Jesus is not the Christ. He is just plain Jesus, a man reputed to have stood up against oppression to be crucified on Pilate's orders. He is hailed as Liberator by the proponents of this new discovery of his message, not as having any part in the line of efficient causality for saving man, individually or as the human collective, but only as motivator or model in the line of exemplary causality.

Fr .1 A Karunaharar Catholic Church,

Chavakcheri, Sri Lanka

blog comments powered by Disqus