Page 4, 25th October 1996

25th October 1996
Page 4
Page 4, 25th October 1996 — Anglican orders: the debate rumbles on

Report an error

Noticed an error on this page?
If you've noticed an error in this article please click here to report it.



Related articles

Anglican Orders Still Lost In The Void?

Page 12 from 4th October 1996

Hume Warns Lambeth On Women Priests

Page 1 from 28th July 1978

Are Catholics Free To Acknowledge Anglican Orders?

Page 11 from 7th November 2008

Al Lo Y,. 8124444

Page 2 from 11th February 1966

Call To Revise Orders Ban

Page 3 from 13th May 1977

Anglican orders: the debate rumbles on

GERARD Nose , ASKS why "has serious theological debate within Catholic circles not been publicly launched" on the subject of the correctness of Apostolicae Curae's judgment on the invalidity of the Anglican ordination rites (Catholic Herald, 4 October).

In the early Eighties Bishop Butler did appeal in The Tablet for someone to explain and defend the theology of Apostolicae Curae. That I did in a lengthy published letter. Bishop Butler did not reply to my defence of Apostolicae Curae, which presupposes the Catholic doctrine of the priesthood as essentially defined by the celebration of Mass being the sacramental renewal of the Sacrifice of the Cross.

Those who accept ARCIC's setting aside of the traditional doctrines on the Eucharist and the priesthood are quite consistent in wishing to set aside the Bull's definitive decision. However, should they succeed, and bring their own ordination rites into doctrinal conformity with the Anglican, then they will fall under Pope Leo XIII's judgment and be held by Catholics to be null and void.

It is interesting to note Cardinal Gasquet's observations on his Roman discussions with eminent pro-Anglican Orders continental ecclesiastics: "It was the most painful meeting we have had. It was impossible to believe that four Catholic priests could have calmly accepted full-blown Protestantism as they did today."

wy Morgan

Monks Kirby, Warks

blog comments powered by Disqus