Page 7, 4th February 2000

4th February 2000
Page 7
Page 7, 4th February 2000 — 'Alarmism' of Winterton Bill

Report an error

Noticed an error on this page?
If you've noticed an error in this article please click here to report it.



Related articles

The Winterton Bill — Action Required

Page 7 from 21st January 2000

Personal Touch Is The Best

Page 4 from 15th February 1985

Winterton Attacks Spuc Mass Lobby

Page 3 from 25th February 2000

Mp's Bid To End Nhs Euthanasia

Page 1 from 17th December 1999

Euthanasia Bill To Return To Parliament

Page 3 from 4th August 2000

'Alarmism' of Winterton Bill

From Mrs Anne Keat RGN

Sir, I write to rebuff the alarming statements made in the letter front Mr Patrick McKay (Jan 21) about the potential lcilling of the disabled. and by implication, the elderly.

After many years nursing and as a sister on a ward in our local community hospital, I have never, ever, experienced his phenomenon and as we also have a physically handicapped son, believe me I would be pretty quick to notice such awful procedures as Mr McKay describes.

You have published several letters lately about Ann Winterton's proposed Bill, and 1 consider it very irresponsible of your letter writers to be so alarmist when as things are at the moment, the examples they hint at would in fact be criminal offences involving the police.

No, Mr McKay, in my mind the much sadder scenario is of elderly patients who just do not want to live any longer so take it upon themselves to refuse all food and medicines, and make it absolutely clear that this is their decision, and we have to respect it. This is usually after the patient has suffered a severe stroke or has a terminal illness and although we can maintain fluid levels by infusions we cannot, and will not, force feed. You could describe this as "withdrawal of treatment" but it is invariably the patients' decision, without a word said. For us, as nurses, it is desperately frustrating, but it happens.

I do not intend to sign, in support, Mrs Winterton's Bill because it does not give a balanced picture.

In the meantime, my colleagues and I will continue to treat and to care for our patients to the very best of our ability.

Yours faithfully, ANNE KEAT

Corsham, Wiltshire.

blog comments powered by Disqus