Page 8, 4th March 1977

4th March 1977
Page 8
Page 8, 4th March 1977 — Montrose by Max Hastings (Gollancx, £7.50)

Report an error

Noticed an error on this page?
If you've noticed an error in this article please click here to report it.


Locations: Edinburgh


Related articles

The Imprint That Cromwell Left Behind Him

Page 6 from 25th September 1970

One View Of The Priest `rebel' Against Society

Page 10 from 30th April 1971

The British Civil War

Page 11 from 16th April 2004

Spain : Another View

Page 3 from 6th November 1942

Imperial Facts And Fantasies

Page 4 from 25th February 1972

Montrose by Max Hastings (Gollancx, £7.50)

Despite the partial rehabilitation of Cromwell and the growing cornplexity of historical studies of the 17th century, most people still see the English Civil War in simple terms. It is all a matter of "cowboys and Indians".

It was, the general opinion goes, a confrontation between good (the "Cavaliers") and bad (the "Roundheads"). The persistence of such an interpretation owes much to the romantic character of many of the leading royalists as compared to the apparently stolid uniformity of the Parliament men.

The popular view is reinforced in

this new biography of James Graham, first Marquess of Montrose — perhaps the most important of the King's men in Scotland.

Mr Hastings is an enthusiast both for Montrose himself and for Scotland — and his book has the merits and disadvantages of the committed.

He brings life not only into the meteoric career of the Marquess, who inspired sufficient leadership in a ragged army of "lrishers" and Highland clansmen to wage — in the King's name — a successful war against the anti-royalist and antiepiscopal "Convenanting" armies in Scotland but also into the campaigns themselves, which he describes with a rare eye for the important detail.

He paints the dramitc last scenes

of Montrose's short life — the 38year-old "King's Champion" going to the gallows in Edinburgh with such dignity that "he humbled the tyrants who ruled Scotland, as surely as ever he had crushed them upon the battlefield."

The world "tyrants" reflects the author's opinion of Montrose's opponents. He offers little sympathy to the opposing side, and glosses over the excesses of Charles's governance which rested heavily on his Scottish subjects.

Even so, despite a lack of balance and occasional over-writing, this book can be recommended for all those who like a good story, with a dramatic (if not a happy) ending, set in a period of exceptional conflict and appeal.

Dominic Bellenger

blog comments powered by Disqus