Page 2, 7th July 1972

7th July 1972
Page 2
Page 2, 7th July 1972 — Women treated by Church as 'ecclesiastical chars'

Report an error

Noticed an error on this page?
If you've noticed an error in this article please click here to report it.


People: Rita Hannon
Locations: Manchester


Related articles

Women 'ecclesiastical Chars'?

Page 5 from 14th July 1972

Sorry Tale Of Exclusion' Says Nun

Page 1 from 13th October 1972

Credibility Gap Over Women's Rights

Page 2 from 9th February 1968

What Some Women Think About Women's Role In The Church

Page 7 from 13th October 1972

Deep Ambivalence On Women's Role Within The Church

Page 5 from 31st March 1978

Women treated by Church as 'ecclesiastical chars'


THE inferior position of women in the Church was as much the fault of women as of men, especially of women members of religious orders, Sister Rita Hannon of La Sainte Union said in Manchester on Saturday. She was addressing a meeting organised by the North-West branch of St. Joan's Alliance.

She argued that "people do not always distinguish between authority and power." Christ had given the Church "authority to teach, to lead and to administer the Sacraments but he had not given it power." On the contrary "he had warned the Apostles against lording it over others.

"Yet," she continued, "the Church has used power. especially psychological power, to subjugate women. It has sought domination in the intellectual, spiritual. religious, sexual and economic spheres."

She said its distrust of feminine intelligence was evidenced in the remarks of St. Augustine. in the reluctance to recognise St. Teresa and in the refusal to grant good academic degrees to women.


By use of Canon Law the Church had accorded women an inferior legal and economic position, "the status of women being lowest in the so-called Catholic countries."

Sister Hannon maintained that women were "excluded from the official ministry on a flimsy basis, such as St. Paul's remarks." While they were welcomed "as ecclesiastical chars" they were not permitted to serve at Mass, "even for nuns in their own chapels."

She continued : "Women religious could have done more, but they are more subdued by male restrictions. They have often deferred to the clergy when, they have been as well able to make decisions.

"Women religious have often flattered the clergy. and have

been responsible for the clergy having an inflated idea of themselves. Why should they entertain a priest lavishly but only give a crust to the poor beggar at the back door?" she asked.

MISNOMER "The vow of chastity was intended to free women from domestic responsibilities in order to give more, but instead, nuns have accepted formality and institutionalisation. They should have pioneered more for the emancipation of women.

"The vow of poverty is a misnomer. Whereas nuns should have been a reproach to the Church, they have fitted into middle-class values in a capitalist society. They have failed to speak out for the oppressed and for women."

Turning to the future, Sister Hannon said that it was time for the religious orders "to put their own house in order."

She continued, "We women must demand changes in Canon Law and insist on liturgical changes. Men must be made to explain their reasons. Why should we always be on the defensive?"

She urged more women to obtain qualifications in theology and "to present themselves for ordination." Others should support those who wish to be ordained.

She concluded, "It is going to be hard to get rid of discrimination. We are not looking for domination by women, but for partnership between the sexes. Women should be accepted and respected in the Church and given their full value because it is all done ultimately for the Kingdom of God."

blog comments powered by Disqus